The edition · Psychiatry
Relaxation training made people worse, and a circadian app cut mood episode recurrence threefold
A component network meta-analysis of 10,612 participants dismantles task-shared psychosocial therapy and finds social support does the work while relaxation does harm, and a sham-controlled trial of a circadian feedback app prevents relapse in mood disorders.
The edition in brief
A Bayesian individual participant data component network meta-analysis pooled 34 randomised trials of task-shared psychosocial interventions for common mental disorders, with individual data from 30 trials and 10,612 participants. Strengthening social support was the most beneficial component (incremental mean difference -9.48, 95% credible interval -13.29 to -6.60), followed by behavioural activation (-4.15, -7.48 to -0.05) and problem management (-4.08, -5.37 to -2.83). Relaxation was detrimental (+7.97, 3.35 to 12.11), as was cognitive reframing less clearly (+5.17, 0.78 to 9.15). Component effects varied by baseline severity. In 676 adolescents with subthreshold depressive and anxiety symptoms, the Unified Protocol for Adolescents was compared with protocolised progressive relaxation as an active control. Both improved symptoms with no significant difference on the primary outcomes; the Unified Protocol was better on hyperactivity, conduct problems and total difficulties, and marginally on depressive symptoms at 12 months. A mega-analysis of individual data from 1,189 participants across 18 magnetic resonance spectroscopy studies found antipsychotic non-responders had raised medial frontal glutamate, glutamate plus glutamine, choline and myo-inositol compared with responders, with small effect sizes. Raised glutamate plus glutamine was seen prospectively in first-episode psychosis. A randomised study of 1,012 US teenagers and young adults found health warnings on a mock social media page were rated more discouraging than a neutral message and more effective than the screen-time break warnings platforms currently use voluntarily. A double-blind sham-controlled trial of a circadian rhythm feedback app in 93 adults with major depressive or bipolar disorder found the sham group had 3.39 times the recurrence rate over 12 months.
Taking psychosocial therapy apart: social support helps most, relaxation appears to harm
In task-shared psychosocial therapy, strengthening social support, behavioural activation and problem management carried the benefit, while relaxation-based content was associated with worse outcomes.
For adolescents with subthreshold symptoms, the protocol mattered less than the group
A transdiagnostic protocol and structured relaxation produced equivalent reductions in adolescent subthreshold depressive and anxiety symptoms, so the deliverable structure matters more than the specific manual.
Antipsychotic non-responders have a different frontal metabolite profile, by a small margin
Antipsychotic non-responders showed raised medial frontal glutamate and glial metabolites even at first episode, but the effect sizes are far too small to identify an individual patient.
Social media health warnings tested, ahead of the laws that would require them
Teenagers and young adults rated specific social media health warnings as more discouraging than the voluntary screen-time reminders platforms currently use, though only perceived effectiveness was measured.
Ask what time they woke up, not how they slept
Record the patient's actual wake time at every visit and treat drift in it as an early sign of destabilisation - a fixed rising time is the first intervention, not a hypnotic.
A circadian feedback app cut mood episode recurrence more than threefold, against a sham
A circadian rhythm feedback app reduced mood episode recurrence more than threefold against a convincing sham, which makes circadian stabilisation an active relapse-prevention treatment rather than lifestyle advice.
Read the rest in the app
You have read your two free briefings this month. The app carries all 27 specialties, every morning, free — and this one is waiting in it.

Scan to keep reading on your phone. No account needed to start.
Tomorrow morning, before your first patient
One edition a day for psychiatry, written by the desk, every claim tied to its paper. Six minutes.
Get the app — free