DailyDoctor Archive Specialties Get app
All radiology briefings

The edition · Radiology

The model helped the residents most, and misled them most

A reader study in thoracic imaging finds the benefit of a language model runs through the expertise of the person using it; a deep learning segmentation beats LAA-950 for emphysema; and ancillary features lift Plaque-RADS where stenosis alone decides nothing.

The edition in brief

Today's radiology edition opens with a reader study of 93 thoracic cases in which ten readers — five thoracic radiologists and five residents — described the findings in free text, fed that description to a large language model, and then chose again. Accuracy rose in both groups, from 56.3% to 65.6% for radiologists and from 42.4% to 58.5% for residents. The residents gained more, but they also accepted the model's preferred diagnosis far more often (73.2% vs 48.9%) and switched to a wrong answer after a misleading output in 60.6% of such cases against 32.4%. The model was also better when a specialist wrote the description than when a resident did. An AJR expert panel sets out why paediatric imaging is so poorly served by artificial intelligence — scarce datasets, developmental variation, off-label use of adult-trained models, absent post-deployment surveillance — and what a paediatric implementation roadmap needs. A deep learning emphysema segmentation outperformed the conventional LAA-950 threshold on Dice accuracy, bias and correlation with visual scores and lung function across three clinical cohorts including 1,159 patients. A prospective study of 34 patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma found a PD-L1-targeted tracer, 68Ga-DOTA-WL12, discriminated PD-L1 positivity far better than FDG (area under the curve 0.92 vs 0.69) and independently predicted chemo-immunotherapy response. The practice-changer is carotid Plaque-RADS, where adding plaque burden, remodelling index, enhancement ratio and perivascular fat density raised discrimination of symptomatic plaque to 0.919 in the moderate-stenosis group that stenosis measurement alone cannot resolve.

In this edition
01
Clinical update

A language model amplifies whatever expertise is holding it

A text-based language model workflow improves diagnostic accuracy for both radiologists and residents, but trainees accept wrong answers at twice the rate — supervise use rather than assuming the tool is self-correcting.

3 min · AJR. American journal of roentgenologyRead →
Primary outcome
reader diagnostic accuracy before and after receiving language model output generated from the reader's own free-text description
Effect
radiologists 56.3% to 65.6%, residents 42.4% to 58.5%; residents accepted model-favoured diagnoses 73.2% vs 48.9% and switched to a wrong answer after misleading output 60.6% vs 32.4%
02Clinical update

Children are being scanned by models trained on adults

Before any artificial intelligence tool touches a paediatric study, establish what age range it was validated in — most were validated on adults, and nobody is monitoring what happens outside that range.

2 min · AJR. American journal of roentgenologyRead →
03Research

A better emphysema number than the −950 threshold

Treat LAA-950 as a within-scanner number only, and say so when reporting change over time — the threshold's limits of agreement are wide enough to swamp real progression.

2 min · European radiologyRead →
04Research

A PET tracer that sees PD-L1, where FDG sees nothing useful

A PD-L1-targeted PET tracer separates PD-L1-positive from negative lesions where FDG cannot, but tissue immunohistochemistry remains the basis for treatment decisions.

2 min · European radiologyRead →
05Pearl

Say what the referrer should do, not only what you saw

Close every incidental finding with a modality, an interval and a stopping condition, and name the framework you used — 'clinical correlation advised' transfers risk without transferring information.

1 minRead →
06
Practice changer

Plaque-RADS earns its keep in the moderate-stenosis carotid

In a carotid with moderate stenosis, report the Plaque-RADS ancillary features — plaque burden, remodelling index, enhancement ratio and perivascular fat density — rather than the stenosis percentage alone.

2 min · European radiologyRead →
Primary outcome
discrimination of symptomatic from asymptomatic carotid plaque
Effect
integrated model area under the curve 0.876 (95% CI 0.828–0.924) overall and 0.919 (0.867–0.971) in the moderate-stenosis subgroup, with greatest net benefit on decision curve analysis

Read the rest in the app

You have read your two free briefings this month. The app carries all 27 specialties, every morning, free — and this one is waiting in it.

QR code to install Daily Doctor
Get Daily Doctor — free

Scan to keep reading on your phone. No account needed to start.

Tomorrow morning, before your first patient

One edition a day for radiology, written by the desk, every claim tied to its paper. Six minutes.

Get the app — free