The edition · Ophthalmology
For children under 8, the HOTV chart cut vision screening referrals and caught more true problems than tumbling E
A head-to-head comparison of screening charts in 995 children closes the edition. Before it: poorer cataract outcomes from outreach camps across 61 countries, aflibercept 8 mg against faricimab in vein occlusion, four years of pegcetacoplan, and depot triamcinolone after phaco.
The edition in brief
In 995 Shanghai children tested with both charts, tumbling E measured vision worse than HOTV by about a line at age 3 and by more than 3 letters up to age 8, converging after that. Among 183 preschoolers, HOTV referred fewer children (18.6% vs 31.2%) while detecting more true cases (true positive rate 0.68 vs 0.44) with better specificity (0.93 vs 0.79). Tumbling E charts are commonly used in child screening in India, so switching to HOTV for under-8s could reduce false referrals. Pooled data from 168 population surveys in 61 countries found cataract surgery in outreach camps less likely to give presenting vision of 6/18 or better than fixed facilities (60.6% vs 66.6%; OR 0.59), with private hospitals doing better than government ones (OR 1.56); gaps did not narrow over 20 years. An indirect comparison of three trials in retinal vein occlusion found aflibercept 8 mg more likely to reach driving vision than faricimab (RR 1.18), while faricimab dried the retina more often and caused fewer post-injection pressure spikes. In the GALE extension, eyes started on pegcetacoplan two years earlier preserved about three times more retinal tissue in non-subfoveal geographic atrophy. A 100-eye Indian trial found a single subconjunctival triamcinolone injection non-inferior to six weeks of topical prednisolone after phacoemulsification, with more subconjunctival haemorrhage. The pearl: do a cycloplegic refraction before labelling a child amblyopic.
Cataract surgery in outreach camps gave poorer vision than fixed facilities, and the gap has not closed
If you run or refer to cataract camps, audit outcomes by setting and close the gap with biometry, postoperative refraction and spectacles.
In retinal vein occlusion, aflibercept 8 mg reached driving vision more often; faricimab dried the macula more often
Both agents give similar visual gains in vein occlusion; check pressure after aflibercept 8 mg injections and choose on access and burden.
Starting pegcetacoplan two years earlier preserved about three times more retina in geographic atrophy
If pegcetacoplan is an option, discuss it while geographic atrophy is still non-subfoveal; delay costs retina that cannot be regained.
One subconjunctival triamcinolone injection controlled post-phaco inflammation as well as six weeks of drops
For patients who cannot manage a post-phaco drop taper, a single subconjunctival triamcinolone injection is a reasonable alternative; check pressure at follow-up.
Refract under cycloplegia before labelling a child amblyopic
Do a cycloplegic refraction and a trial of spectacles before diagnosing amblyopia in a child who fails screening.
HOTV screening in young children reduced false referrals and found more true cases than tumbling E
Switch vision screening in children under 8 from tumbling E to HOTV charts to reduce false referrals and catch more real problems.
Read the rest in the app
You have read your two free briefings this month. The app carries all 27 specialties, every morning, free — and this one is waiting in it.

Scan to keep reading on your phone. No account needed to start.
Tomorrow morning, before your first patient
One edition a day for ophthalmology, written by the desk, every claim tied to its paper. Six minutes.
Get the app — free